No-name nomination papers for Bowman, familiar figures back Motkaluk in Winnipeg mayoral race - Action News
Home WebMail Saturday, November 23, 2024, 07:45 AM | Calgary | -12.2°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
ManitobaAnalysis

No-name nomination papers for Bowman, familiar figures back Motkaluk in Winnipeg mayoral race

The nomination documents submitted by Brian Bowman and Jenny Motkaluk paint pictures of two entirely different networks of support. And it's unclear whether this is by happenstance or design.

By happenstance or design, nomination documents paint different pictures of support for mayoral frontrunners

Winnipeg mayoral candidates Jenny Motkaluk and Brian Bowman speak at a mayoral forum on environmental policy at the University of Winnipeg's Eckhardt-Grammatt Hall on Tuesday, Sept. 18, 2018. (CBC)

Brian Bowman's re-election nomination papers contain the signatures of so few recognizable Winnipeggers, it's almost as if the incumbent mayor went out of his way to create the appearance of a candidate who knows no one of importance or influence.

Mayoral challenger Jenny Motkaluk's nomination list includes former mayor Sam Katz's most trusted lieutenant on city council, Conservative politicians and a handful of well-known businesspeople, suggesting she'sunconcerned about revealing some of the power associated with her campaign.

The nomination documents submitted by Bowman and Motkalukpaint pictures of two entirely different networks of support. And it's unclear whether this is by happenstance or design.

In order to wind up on the ballot on Oct. 24, mayoral candidates had submit 250 nomination signatures by Tuesday afternoon. Their respectivelists can be viewed atthe city clerk's office but are not posted online.

CBCNews went through the nomination papers and found the most recognizable names in Bowman's nomination papers arecurrent or former employees of the mayor's office, including chief of staff JasonFuith, press secretary Jeremy Davis, administrative assistant Dana Lorentz and former policy advisor Carmen Barnett.

Aside from BrianScharfstein, who owns Canadian Footwear and sits on the Winnipeg Police Board, there are few well-known names embedded in Bowman's nomination list.

Brian Scharfstein, principal owner of Canadian Footwear, signed incumbent mayor Brian Bowman's re-election nomination papers. (CBC)

The incumbent said he was not trying to portray himself as an ordinary Joeby eschewing the signatures of more notable nominees the kinds of people you would expect to operate within the orbit of a sitting mayor.

"There wasn't a deliberate kind of scientific strategy," Bowman said Friday in an interview. "As volunteers were out and about in the community, for people that were willing to sign, we asked them to sign."

'Broad cross section' for Motkaluk

Motkaluk'snomination papers are studded with far more recognizable names, such as former St. Norbert councillor Justin Swandel, who served on Katz's executive policy committee for most of his nine years on council and then went to work for industrial landdeveloper Terracon.

Conservative Sen. Don Plett, former Winnipeg South Centre Tory MP Joyce Bateman and former River HeightsPC MLA Michael Radcliffe all nominated Motkaluk, as did sitting North Kildonan Coun. Jeff Browaty, Charleswood-Tuxedo council hopeful Kevin Klein and Manitoba Liberal Leader Dougald Lamont.

Other notable Motkaluk nominees include grocery owner Tom De Nardi, auto dealer Jim Gauthier and lawyer Robert Tapper.

Former St. Norbert councillor Justin Swandel, who served on Sam Katz's EPC, signed mayoral candidate Jenny Motkaluk's nomination forms. (CBC)

Motkaluk's campaign describes hersupport network as widespread, non-partisan and unconnected to special interests.

"Jenny's nomination list proudly features a broad cross section of business leaders, concerned citizens and elected officials from across the entire political spectrum," campaign spokesperson Dave MacKay said in a statement.

Bowman claimed the list is evidence Motkalukwould be beholden to unions and developers.

"We saw at her launchmany of the old figures that used to call the shots at city hall," he said, repeating a claim he made at his own campaign launch last week.

Motkalukherself was unavailable for comment this weekend. She's planning a campaign rally that's slated forMonday evening.

Bowman to reveal donor identities

As the mayoral race continues, expect Bowman to continue to attempt to portray himself as more transparent than his competition.

On Wednesday, Bowman pledged toreveal the identity of hiscampaign donors prior to theOct. 24 election. He also challenged other mayoral candidates to do the same.

It's unclear whether Motkaluk will follow suit. Over the summer, she said she did not intend to reveal the identity of her donors before election day.

Mayoral candidates Brian Bowman and Jenny Motkaluk shake hands during a cordial moment following a forum at the University of Winnipeg on Tuesday. (John Einarson/CBC)

The identity of all donors who make contributions of $250 or more must be disclosed in campaign finance paperwork the city clerk will make public in 2019.

The incumbent mayor's strategy appears to be to portray his primary challenger as trying to hide her funding sources.

How effective that will be is unclear, asMotkalukobviouslyhad no concern about revealing some of her connections when her campaign submitted nomination paperwork.