St. John's shuts down Bannerman bathrooms, blaming increased vandalism with tent encampment nearby

As a tent encampment protest continues near Colonial Building in St. John's, city councilis closing the bathrooms at nearby Bannerman Park, blaming vandalismthe city says has damaged the bathrooms' plumbing and hardware, and a lack of staff to keep them clean.

St. John's Mayor Danny Breen says the bathrooms pose health and safety issues for park visitors and staff.

"There's been a significant amount of damage done to the bathrooms. You know, there's such things as toilets ripped from the floor, there's been human waste on the floor. Clogged toilets and sinks with needles, and it just created a very unhealthy situation and a significant amount of damage," St. John's Mayor Danny Breen told reporters at city hall Wednesday.

"The staff said that no longer were they willing to work in those conditions, so we don't have the staff to clean up and to keep the washrooms in the condition that they're required to be [in] to be healthy. So we were forced into the situation of closing them."

The announcement comes two days after Memorial University social work students and their professor deposited a porcelain toilet at city hallto urge the city tokeep Bannerman Park bathrooms open after 8 p.m. forthe people living in the encampment.

Instead, the city is asking the provincial governmentto provide porta-potties on Colonial Building grounds.

John Abbott, minister of transportation and infrastructure, said that won't be happening.

"If the city is changing access to the public facility, that's up for them to respond to," he said.

St. Johns mayor says city closed park bathrooms because of major damage, but advocates demand city do more

9 months ago

Duration 1:46

St. Johns Mayor Danny Breen says city maintenance staff refused to enter the now-closed Bannerman Park bathrooms citing broken toilets, needles and human waste in the stalls. The city is asking the provincial government to bring in porta-potties for people living in tents nearby. MUN professor Julia Janes, who earlier this week led a protest over the issue, says many public washrooms have cleanliness issues but shutting these ones is unacceptable.

Abbott said portable toilets aren't a solution to bigger problem of homelessness.

"What we want and what we're encouraging for each individual that's down there is to take up our offer for shelter, and other supportive housing, and then we will work with them in terms of a long-term solution."

Breen said he hopes the provincial government will take actionbut said the situation isn't aboutfinger-pointing.

"We don't have a lot of flexibility here. We don't have the staff to clean, or to maintain the washrooms. So we do have a problem, but hopefully we can figure out some way to address the situation with the province," he said.

"When you look at the night that we're expecting tonight, I mean, the Colonial Building grounds are no place for people to be living. So we really need to find them safe and supportive housing."

Ahead of Wednesday evening's snowstorm, the province is advising people at the encampment to contact itsemergency shelter line 1-833-724-2444 for assistance with temporary accommodations.

Breenencouraged residents of the encampment to go to the warming centre established at the Safe Haven Shelter on St. Clare Avenue to get out of the impending weather, but acknowledged transportation would have to be arranged.

'I'm scared people are going to die'

As of Monday, there were about 30 people living at thetent encampment, set up shortly after a similar one was established on Confederation Hill to protest the province's homelessness problem.

The Confederation Hill location exposed people to high winds and it eventually dissolved, with some people moving to the rear of the downtown Colonial Building, which is better shielded from the elements.

Nicole Noble, who lives in the camp, says she's upset the bathrooms have been closed.

"I lost faith. I cried, I screamed. I totally just said there is no God if this is going on," she said. "I'm scared people are going to die."

MUN social work professor Julia Janes, who was part of Monday's protest, called the decision to close the washrooms a "ridiculous turn of events." She saidstaffing isn't a good enough reason to close them.

"It's distracting us from the end goal, and the end goal is housing for all, immediately," she said.

"We need to step up maintenance. This is a maintenance issue, and the city has the capacity to do so. This is a matter of survival."

Download our free CBC News app to sign up for push alerts for CBC Newfoundland and Labrador. Click here to visit our landing page.