Appeal of conviction in murder of Loretta Saunders begins today - Action News
Home WebMail Saturday, November 23, 2024, 10:46 AM | Calgary | -12.0°C | Regions Advertise Login | Our platform is in maintenance mode. Some URLs may not be available. |
Nova Scotia

Appeal of conviction in murder of Loretta Saunders begins today

Victoria Henneberry, convicted of second-degree murder in killing of Loretta Saunders, argues her own case before the Nova Scotia Court of Appeal.

Victoria Henneberry expected to argue her own case after conviction for second-degree murder

Victoria Henneberry, 28, is escorted into Halifax provincial court on Feb. 28, 2014. (Mike Dembeck/The Canadian Press)

$430.

That's how much Blake Leggette and Victoria Henneberry owed Loretta Saunders for rent to sublet her apartment in the Cowie Hill neighbourhood of Halifax.

Rather than pay that rent, Leggette and Henneberry murdered Saunders, stuffed her body in a hockey bag and took off for Ontario in her car. They stopped long enough to dispose of her remains in the woods alongside the Trans-Canada Highway in New Brunswick.

Henneberry to argue own case

Today, Henneberryis expected tobegin arguing her own case in the appeal of her second-degree murder conviction.

Henneberry's handwritten notice of appeal came long after the official appeal period for her crime had expired. She argued in her notice that she'd been told she had more time, and wasn't aware it had run out.

The Nova Scotia Court of Appeal agreed to hear Henneberry's arguments, howeveritrefused herrequest to appoint a lawyer to assist her in theappeal.

Because of public interest in this case, the Court of Appeal has agreed to live stream the proceedings on its website.

Saunders, a 26-year-old Inuk woman from Labrador, disappeared just before Valentine's Day in2014. Leggette and Henneberry were arrested in southern Ontario a short time later, still in possession of Saunders's car and bank cards.

A young Inuk woman wearing a black shirt sits on a red chair.
Loretta Saunders was studying the issue of murdered or missing aboriginal women when she was killed. (Gofundme)

Just as their case was to go to trial in April of 2015, they both pleaded guilty Leggette to first-degree murder and Henneberry to second-degree. They each got a life sentence.

Leggette must serve 25 years before he can begin applying for parole. Henneberry must serve 10.

Handwritten appeal claims innocence

But ever since the summer of 2015, Henneberry has been trying to rewrite that narrative. In a handwritten notice of appeal filed from her cell atthe Nova Institution for Women, a women's prison in Truro, N.S., Henneberry protested her innocence.

She wrotethat at the time of the murder she was under a great deal of "stress, fear, anxiety."

She claimed she experienced a panic attack due to a pre-existing condition and failed to appreciate what her guilty plea would mean. She also did her best to pin the murder entirely on her then-boyfriend, Leggette.

"Had I been aware of his intentions prior, I would have done what I could to deter him from committing such a heinous, callous, selfish and pointless offence which would have saved Ms. Saunders' life," Henneberry wrote.

Leggettenot appealing conviction

Leggette is not joining in Henneberry's appeal. He paints a much different picture of her level of involvement in thecrime.

When police searched his cell at the Central Nova Scotia Correctional Facility in Burnside where he was being held awaiting trial, they recovered notes which appeared to be a draft for a book Leggette planned to write on his experiences.

In those notes, Leggette suggested Henneberry was an equal partner in the murder, helping him to smother the young woman as she fought for her life.

There is also cellphone video that was played at the couple's preliminary inquiry. On that video, the pair can be heard discussing the idea of killing Saunders, a couple of weeks before the murder happened.

In her appeal notice, Henneberry admits there is enough evidence to convict her of being an accessory to murder after the fact, but not to convict her of murder.

Loretta Saunders's mother, Miriam, has said the appeal process keeps "the wounds fresh" for her family. (CBC)

Family 'victimized'by appeal

News of the appeal has prolonged the suffering for Saunders's family.

"It seems like they keep the wounds fresh," hermother, Miriam, said in a text message to CBC News earlier in the appeal process.

She said it continues to "haunt the victim's family and we keep getting victimized."

Two days have been set aside for theappeal.