This Is The Controversy Behind Oprah's Latest Book Club Pick, 'American Dirt'

Oprah Winfrey s latest Oprahs Book Club pick, American Dirt, has social media and news outlets arguing over whether the book is an extraordinary piece of work or cringeworthy and real problematic.

On Tuesday, Winfrey touted the Jeanine Cummins novel as a story that changed the way I see what it means to be a migrant in a whole new way. In a video of her endorsement, the media mogul said, I was shook up, it woke me up, and I feel that everybody who reads this book is actually going to be immersed in the experience of what it means to be a migrant on the run for freedom. So I want you to read.

Our next book club selection is American Dirt by @jeaninecummins. Its a heart-wrenching page-turner, and you wont be able to put it down.

Download your copy on @applebooks and #ReadWithUs: https://t.co/w62380H4Lz #AmericanDirt@Flatironbooks @Oprah pic.twitter.com/v6K23tEyPM

Oprah's Book Club (@oprahsbookclub) January 21, 2020","type":"rich","meta":{"author":"Oprah's Book Club","author_url":"https://twitter.com/oprahsbookclub","cache_age":86400,"description":"Our next book club selection is American Dirt by @jeaninecummins. Its a heart-wrenching page-turner, and you wont be able to put it down.Download your copy on @applebooks and #ReadWithUs: https://t.co/w62380H4Lz #AmericanDirt@Flatironbooks @Oprah pic.twitter.com/v6K23tEyPM Oprah's Book Club (@oprahsbookclub) January 21, 2020\n\n","options":{"_hide_media":{"label":"Hide photos, videos, and cards","value":false}},"provider_name":"Twitter","thumbnail_height":1200,"thumbnail_url":"https://pbs.twimg.com/ext_tw_video_thumb/1219620244873826305/pu/img/aNGBrysDddyiB6k-.jpg","thumbnail_width":675,"title":"Oprah's Book Club on Twitter","type":"rich","url":"https://twitter.com/oprahsbookclub/status/1219620561086631937","version":"1.0"},"flags":[],"fullBleed":false,"options":{"theme":"archive","device":"mobile","editionInfo":{"id":"us","name":"U.S.","link":"https://action.news","locale":"en_US"},"originalEdition":"au","isMapi":false,"isAmp":false,"isVideoEntry":false,"isEntry":true,"isMt":false,"entryId":"5e28b69bc5b6d6767fce70e7","entryPermalink":"https://action.news/archive/au/entry/controversy-behind-oprahs-latest-book-club-pick-american-dirt_au_5e28b69bc5b6d6767fce70e7","entryTagsList":"culture-arts,oprah-winfrey,brownface,jeanine-cummins,fiction,literary-criticism,@chubwidget","sectionSlug":"entertainment","deptSlug":null,"sectionRedirectUrl":null,"subcategories":"","isWide":false,"headerOverride":null,"noVideoAds":false,"disableFloat":false,"isNative":false,"commercialVideo":{"provider":"custom","site_and_category":"us.entertainment","package":null},"isHighline":false,"vidibleConfigValues":{"cid":"60afc111dcf87c2cd2f5d8bf","overrides":{"front_page_top_videos":{"desktop":"60b64354b171b7444beaff4d","mobileweb":"60b64354b171b7444beaff4d"},"top_media":{"desktop":"60b8e6bdc5449357a7ada147","mobile":"60b8e701c5449357a7ada2ee","iphone":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","ipad":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","androidphone":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c","androidtablet":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c"},"anthology":{"desktop":"60b8e616cdd90620331bb0ba","mobile":"60b8e671c5449357a7ad9f66","iphone":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","ipad":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","androidphone":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c","androidtablet":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c"},"content":{"desktop":"60b8e616cdd90620331bb0ba","mobile":"60b8e671c5449357a7ad9f66","iphone":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","ipad":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","androidphone":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c","androidtablet":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c"}},"playerUpdates":{"5668ae6ee4b0b5e26955d6a6":"60d2472d9340d7032ad7e443","56aa41bae4b091744c0440d8":"60e869dc7c5f3b17b6741b81","5841b2b5cc52c716ec6e5a7f":"60b8e355cdd90620331ba185","58b5e2b8d85a10302feee895":"60b64316b171b7444beafdb2","58b74698f78ced31417819ae":"60b8e5bec5449357a7ad9b52","58b74ccecebcea57e2c3a3d1":"60b8e5eac5449357a7ad9ca5","58cff690d85a100b9992bc39":"60b8e616cdd90620331bb0ba","58cffb3fb6d9b972a49a3c9d":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","58cffdd74d96935d7d6ec180":"60b8e671c5449357a7ad9f66","58d03a84f78ced6518eb2fa7":"60b643c82e76be41f112735c","592edf20e0fa177b0c26f7fd":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c","5b35266b158f855373e28256":"60b64354b171b7444beaff4d","5c116f29f79c4171d82b7c2a":"60b64440b171b7444beb040b","5c1170fc600c9a697bf0c6b9":"60b646102e76be41f1127ffc","5c47791afa1b317df8ae0c4f":"60b8e6bdc5449357a7ada147","5c477987a6b48b35f164773d":"60b8e701c5449357a7ada2ee","5c4779ee943c3c2a64f28371":"60b8e747cdd90620331bb861","5c477a26fcd67b26879bc7c2":"60b8e788c5449357a7ada67b","5d8921a78c3ae845f366c9b6":"60ae7be5f3a7c13a30417ff9","58b98b00ba82aa39a6534321":"60d0de7c9340d7032ad1146c","58b9d14cb6d9b96c9ec32af3":"60d0dec19340d7032ad115a0","58cff8eccebcea42931e0436":"60d0e005b627221e9d819d44","592edf5de0fa177b0c26f95b":"60d0e38fb627221e9d81adcf","58cff72fd85a100b9992c112":"60d0e447b627221e9d81b0da","56b4d34fe4b022697697c400":"60d2472d9340d7032ad7e443","60b8e4c0c5449357a7ad957d":"60e869dc7c5f3b17b6741b81"}},"connatixConfigValues":{"defaultPlayer":"ff7fdddc-5441-4253-abc4-f12a33fad58b","clickToPlayPlayer":"d014396e-b366-4c17-aeac-3ce906fa3fd0","videoPagePlayer":"f010447b-d244-4111-a314-7b4542ae4145","verticalPlayer":"e58cb05a-0bc8-4210-9108-fea82726c065","stickyPlayerControl":"52ea1755-d601-4ad1-bccc-d8cce3f0e5da","stickyPlayerON":"8055e9e5-3bda-4933-8d45-9ad814fb6e22"},"topConnatixThumnbailSrc":"","customAmpComponents":[],"ampAssetsUrl":"https://amp.assets.huffpost.com","videoTraits":null,"positionInUnitCounts":{"buzz_head":{"count":0},"buzz_body":{"count":0},"buzz_bottom":{"count":0}},"positionInSubUnitCounts":{"article_body":{"count":17},"blog_summary":{"count":0},"before_you_go_content":{"count":0}},"connatixCountsHelper":{"count":0},"buzzfeedTracking":{"context_page_id":"5e28b69bc5b6d6767fce70e7","context_page_type":"buzz","destination":"huffpost","mode":"mobile","page_edition":"en-us"},"tags":[{"name":"Culture & Arts","slug":"culture-arts","links":{"relativeLink":"news/culture-arts","permalink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/culture-arts","mobileWebLink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/culture-arts"},"url":"https://action.news/archive/au/topic/culture-arts"},{"name":"oprah winfrey","slug":"oprah-winfrey","links":{"relativeLink":"news/oprah-winfrey","permalink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/oprah-winfrey","mobileWebLink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/oprah-winfrey"},"url":"https://action.news/archive/au/topic/oprah-winfrey"},{"name":"brownface","slug":"brownface","links":{"relativeLink":"news/brownface","permalink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/brownface","mobileWebLink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/brownface"},"url":"https://action.news/archive/au/topic/brownface"},{"name":"jeanine cummins","slug":"jeanine-cummins","links":{"relativeLink":"news/jeanine-cummins","permalink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/jeanine-cummins","mobileWebLink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/jeanine-cummins"},"url":"https://action.news/archive/au/topic/jeanine-cummins"},{"name":"fiction","slug":"fiction","links":{"relativeLink":"news/fiction","permalink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/fiction","mobileWebLink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/fiction"},"url":"https://action.news/archive/au/topic/fiction"},{"name":"Literary criticism","slug":"literary-criticism","links":{"relativeLink":"news/literary-criticism","permalink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/literary-criticism","mobileWebLink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/literary-criticism"},"url":"https://action.news/archive/au/topic/literary-criticism"}],"isLiveblogLive":null,"isLiveblog":false,"cetUnit":"buzz_body","bodyAds":["

\r\n\r\n","

\r\n\r\n"],"adCount":0},"isCollectionEmbed":false,"enhancements":{}}">

Our next book club selection is American Dirt by @jeaninecummins . Its a heart-wrenching page-turner, and you wont be able to put it down.

Download your copy on @applebooks and #ReadWithUs : https://t.co/w62380H4Lz #AmericanDirt @Flatironbooks @Oprah pic.twitter.com/v6K23tEyPM
Oprah's Book Club (@oprahsbookclub) January 21, 2020

Considered one of the most anticipated books of 2020 , American Dirt follows Lydia Quixano Perez, a woman who runs a bookstore in Acapulco, Mexico. When the boss of the citys newest drug cartel becomes the subject of a tell-all profile by Lydias journalist husband, the couple and their son Luca find themselves on the run and become migrants.

The book has been praised by authors like Stephen King and John Grisham , while Lauren Groff hailed it in The New York Times as propulsive and written with good intentions. But many writers and book critics have said the book tells the story of a Mexican family through a reductionist, white lens.

According to many reviews , the books central problem is brownface . Some critics have drawn attention to Cummins identity (the author, who is of Irish-Puerto Rican heritage, describes herself on Twitter as Irlandaisa/Boricua/Persona but she has also identified herself as white ) and are questioning the accuracy of her portrayal of Mexican immigrants.

Latina or no, Cummins certainly isnt Mexican or Chicana. Thats a problem, writer David Bowles explains in a Medium post where he also calls the novel harmful, appropriating, inaccurate, trauma-porn melodrama.

Bowles take echoes much of what Latinx writer Myriam Gurba wrote in a piece titled, Pendeja, You Aint Steinbeck: My Bronca with Fake-Ass Social Justice Literature about Cummins novel. Gurba claims Cummins clumsy and distorted spectacle is another example of a white writer appropriating genius works by people of color and repackaging them for mass racially colorblind consumption.

Writer David Schmidt noted in The Blue Nib that while the book takes place in Mexico, anyone who has spent significant time in Mexico, however, will find this novel to be laughably inaccurate.

An alternate New York Times review by Parul Sehgal described American Dirt as conspicuously like the work of an outsider and argued that Cummins has a strange, excited fascination in commenting on gradients of brown skin. (Sehgal added, however, that the real failures of the book ... have little to do with the writers identity and everything to do with her abilities as a novelist.)

On Twitter, Los Angeles Times writer Esmeralda Bermudez, an immigrant who has covered Latino culture for more than 15 years, blasted the novel as a cheap, stereotypical thrill:

I am an immigrant. My family fled El Salvador with death pounding on our door. The terror, the loss, the injustice of this experience shaped everything about me. I see no part of myself reflected in #AmericanDirt, a book white critics are hailing as the great immigrant novel.

Esmeralda Bermudez (@LATBermudez) January 20, 2020","type":"rich","meta":{"author":"Esmeralda Bermudez","author_url":"https://twitter.com/LATBermudez","cache_age":86400,"description":"I am an immigrant. My family fled El Salvador with death pounding on our door. The terror, the loss, the injustice of this experience shaped everything about me. I see no part of myself reflected in #AmericanDirt, a book white critics are hailing as the great immigrant novel. Esmeralda Bermudez (@LATBermudez) January 20, 2020\n\n","provider_name":"Twitter","title":"Esmeralda Bermudez on Twitter","type":"rich","url":"https://twitter.com/LATBermudez/status/1219262272993759233","version":"1.0"},"flags":[],"fullBleed":false,"options":{"theme":"archive","device":"mobile","editionInfo":{"id":"us","name":"U.S.","link":"https://action.news","locale":"en_US"},"originalEdition":"au","isMapi":false,"isAmp":false,"isVideoEntry":false,"isEntry":true,"isMt":false,"entryId":"5e28b69bc5b6d6767fce70e7","entryPermalink":"https://action.news/archive/au/entry/controversy-behind-oprahs-latest-book-club-pick-american-dirt_au_5e28b69bc5b6d6767fce70e7","entryTagsList":"culture-arts,oprah-winfrey,brownface,jeanine-cummins,fiction,literary-criticism,@chubwidget","sectionSlug":"entertainment","deptSlug":null,"sectionRedirectUrl":null,"subcategories":"","isWide":false,"headerOverride":null,"noVideoAds":false,"disableFloat":false,"isNative":false,"commercialVideo":{"provider":"custom","site_and_category":"us.entertainment","package":null},"isHighline":false,"vidibleConfigValues":{"cid":"60afc111dcf87c2cd2f5d8bf","overrides":{"front_page_top_videos":{"desktop":"60b64354b171b7444beaff4d","mobileweb":"60b64354b171b7444beaff4d"},"top_media":{"desktop":"60b8e6bdc5449357a7ada147","mobile":"60b8e701c5449357a7ada2ee","iphone":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","ipad":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","androidphone":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c","androidtablet":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c"},"anthology":{"desktop":"60b8e616cdd90620331bb0ba","mobile":"60b8e671c5449357a7ad9f66","iphone":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","ipad":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","androidphone":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c","androidtablet":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c"},"content":{"desktop":"60b8e616cdd90620331bb0ba","mobile":"60b8e671c5449357a7ad9f66","iphone":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","ipad":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","androidphone":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c","androidtablet":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c"}},"playerUpdates":{"5668ae6ee4b0b5e26955d6a6":"60d2472d9340d7032ad7e443","56aa41bae4b091744c0440d8":"60e869dc7c5f3b17b6741b81","5841b2b5cc52c716ec6e5a7f":"60b8e355cdd90620331ba185","58b5e2b8d85a10302feee895":"60b64316b171b7444beafdb2","58b74698f78ced31417819ae":"60b8e5bec5449357a7ad9b52","58b74ccecebcea57e2c3a3d1":"60b8e5eac5449357a7ad9ca5","58cff690d85a100b9992bc39":"60b8e616cdd90620331bb0ba","58cffb3fb6d9b972a49a3c9d":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","58cffdd74d96935d7d6ec180":"60b8e671c5449357a7ad9f66","58d03a84f78ced6518eb2fa7":"60b643c82e76be41f112735c","592edf20e0fa177b0c26f7fd":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c","5b35266b158f855373e28256":"60b64354b171b7444beaff4d","5c116f29f79c4171d82b7c2a":"60b64440b171b7444beb040b","5c1170fc600c9a697bf0c6b9":"60b646102e76be41f1127ffc","5c47791afa1b317df8ae0c4f":"60b8e6bdc5449357a7ada147","5c477987a6b48b35f164773d":"60b8e701c5449357a7ada2ee","5c4779ee943c3c2a64f28371":"60b8e747cdd90620331bb861","5c477a26fcd67b26879bc7c2":"60b8e788c5449357a7ada67b","5d8921a78c3ae845f366c9b6":"60ae7be5f3a7c13a30417ff9","58b98b00ba82aa39a6534321":"60d0de7c9340d7032ad1146c","58b9d14cb6d9b96c9ec32af3":"60d0dec19340d7032ad115a0","58cff8eccebcea42931e0436":"60d0e005b627221e9d819d44","592edf5de0fa177b0c26f95b":"60d0e38fb627221e9d81adcf","58cff72fd85a100b9992c112":"60d0e447b627221e9d81b0da","56b4d34fe4b022697697c400":"60d2472d9340d7032ad7e443","60b8e4c0c5449357a7ad957d":"60e869dc7c5f3b17b6741b81"}},"connatixConfigValues":{"defaultPlayer":"ff7fdddc-5441-4253-abc4-f12a33fad58b","clickToPlayPlayer":"d014396e-b366-4c17-aeac-3ce906fa3fd0","videoPagePlayer":"f010447b-d244-4111-a314-7b4542ae4145","verticalPlayer":"e58cb05a-0bc8-4210-9108-fea82726c065","stickyPlayerControl":"52ea1755-d601-4ad1-bccc-d8cce3f0e5da","stickyPlayerON":"8055e9e5-3bda-4933-8d45-9ad814fb6e22"},"topConnatixThumnbailSrc":"","customAmpComponents":[],"ampAssetsUrl":"https://amp.assets.huffpost.com","videoTraits":null,"positionInUnitCounts":{"buzz_head":{"count":0},"buzz_body":{"count":0},"buzz_bottom":{"count":0}},"positionInSubUnitCounts":{"article_body":{"count":17},"blog_summary":{"count":0},"before_you_go_content":{"count":0}},"connatixCountsHelper":{"count":0},"buzzfeedTracking":{"context_page_id":"5e28b69bc5b6d6767fce70e7","context_page_type":"buzz","destination":"huffpost","mode":"mobile","page_edition":"en-us"},"tags":[{"name":"Culture & Arts","slug":"culture-arts","links":{"relativeLink":"news/culture-arts","permalink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/culture-arts","mobileWebLink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/culture-arts"},"url":"https://action.news/archive/au/topic/culture-arts"},{"name":"oprah winfrey","slug":"oprah-winfrey","links":{"relativeLink":"news/oprah-winfrey","permalink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/oprah-winfrey","mobileWebLink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/oprah-winfrey"},"url":"https://action.news/archive/au/topic/oprah-winfrey"},{"name":"brownface","slug":"brownface","links":{"relativeLink":"news/brownface","permalink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/brownface","mobileWebLink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/brownface"},"url":"https://action.news/archive/au/topic/brownface"},{"name":"jeanine cummins","slug":"jeanine-cummins","links":{"relativeLink":"news/jeanine-cummins","permalink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/jeanine-cummins","mobileWebLink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/jeanine-cummins"},"url":"https://action.news/archive/au/topic/jeanine-cummins"},{"name":"fiction","slug":"fiction","links":{"relativeLink":"news/fiction","permalink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/fiction","mobileWebLink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/fiction"},"url":"https://action.news/archive/au/topic/fiction"},{"name":"Literary criticism","slug":"literary-criticism","links":{"relativeLink":"news/literary-criticism","permalink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/literary-criticism","mobileWebLink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/literary-criticism"},"url":"https://action.news/archive/au/topic/literary-criticism"}],"isLiveblogLive":null,"isLiveblog":false,"cetUnit":"buzz_body","bodyAds":["

\r\n\r\n","

\r\n\r\n"],"adCount":0},"isCollectionEmbed":false,"enhancements":{}}">

I am an immigrant. My family fled El Salvador with death pounding on our door. The terror, the loss, the injustice of this experience shaped everything about me. I see no part of myself reflected in #AmericanDirt , a book white critics are hailing as the great immigrant novel.
Esmeralda Bermudez (@LATBermudez) January 20, 2020

What I do see: A book industry thats so out of touch that so rarely supports immigrants to tell our own stories eager to make money off of our suffering with a cheap, stereotypical thrill. #ImNotAmericanDirt. Neither is any immigrant Ive known in 17 years of journalism.

Esmeralda Bermudez (@LATBermudez) January 20, 2020","type":"rich","meta":{"author":"Esmeralda Bermudez","author_url":"https://twitter.com/LATBermudez","cache_age":86400,"description":"What I do see: A book industry thats so out of touch that so rarely supports immigrants to tell our own stories eager to make money off of our suffering with a cheap, stereotypical thrill. #ImNotAmericanDirt. Neither is any immigrant Ive known in 17 years of journalism. Esmeralda Bermudez (@LATBermudez) January 20, 2020\n\n","options":{"_hide_thread":{"label":"Hide previous Tweet in conversation thread","value":true}},"provider_name":"Twitter","title":"Esmeralda Bermudez on Twitter","type":"rich","url":"https://twitter.com/LATBermudez/status/1219262784694697984","version":"1.0"},"flags":[],"fullBleed":false,"options":{"theme":"archive","device":"mobile","editionInfo":{"id":"us","name":"U.S.","link":"https://action.news","locale":"en_US"},"originalEdition":"au","isMapi":false,"isAmp":false,"isVideoEntry":false,"isEntry":true,"isMt":false,"entryId":"5e28b69bc5b6d6767fce70e7","entryPermalink":"https://action.news/archive/au/entry/controversy-behind-oprahs-latest-book-club-pick-american-dirt_au_5e28b69bc5b6d6767fce70e7","entryTagsList":"culture-arts,oprah-winfrey,brownface,jeanine-cummins,fiction,literary-criticism,@chubwidget","sectionSlug":"entertainment","deptSlug":null,"sectionRedirectUrl":null,"subcategories":"","isWide":false,"headerOverride":null,"noVideoAds":false,"disableFloat":false,"isNative":false,"commercialVideo":{"provider":"custom","site_and_category":"us.entertainment","package":null},"isHighline":false,"vidibleConfigValues":{"cid":"60afc111dcf87c2cd2f5d8bf","overrides":{"front_page_top_videos":{"desktop":"60b64354b171b7444beaff4d","mobileweb":"60b64354b171b7444beaff4d"},"top_media":{"desktop":"60b8e6bdc5449357a7ada147","mobile":"60b8e701c5449357a7ada2ee","iphone":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","ipad":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","androidphone":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c","androidtablet":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c"},"anthology":{"desktop":"60b8e616cdd90620331bb0ba","mobile":"60b8e671c5449357a7ad9f66","iphone":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","ipad":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","androidphone":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c","androidtablet":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c"},"content":{"desktop":"60b8e616cdd90620331bb0ba","mobile":"60b8e671c5449357a7ad9f66","iphone":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","ipad":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","androidphone":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c","androidtablet":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c"}},"playerUpdates":{"5668ae6ee4b0b5e26955d6a6":"60d2472d9340d7032ad7e443","56aa41bae4b091744c0440d8":"60e869dc7c5f3b17b6741b81","5841b2b5cc52c716ec6e5a7f":"60b8e355cdd90620331ba185","58b5e2b8d85a10302feee895":"60b64316b171b7444beafdb2","58b74698f78ced31417819ae":"60b8e5bec5449357a7ad9b52","58b74ccecebcea57e2c3a3d1":"60b8e5eac5449357a7ad9ca5","58cff690d85a100b9992bc39":"60b8e616cdd90620331bb0ba","58cffb3fb6d9b972a49a3c9d":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","58cffdd74d96935d7d6ec180":"60b8e671c5449357a7ad9f66","58d03a84f78ced6518eb2fa7":"60b643c82e76be41f112735c","592edf20e0fa177b0c26f7fd":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c","5b35266b158f855373e28256":"60b64354b171b7444beaff4d","5c116f29f79c4171d82b7c2a":"60b64440b171b7444beb040b","5c1170fc600c9a697bf0c6b9":"60b646102e76be41f1127ffc","5c47791afa1b317df8ae0c4f":"60b8e6bdc5449357a7ada147","5c477987a6b48b35f164773d":"60b8e701c5449357a7ada2ee","5c4779ee943c3c2a64f28371":"60b8e747cdd90620331bb861","5c477a26fcd67b26879bc7c2":"60b8e788c5449357a7ada67b","5d8921a78c3ae845f366c9b6":"60ae7be5f3a7c13a30417ff9","58b98b00ba82aa39a6534321":"60d0de7c9340d7032ad1146c","58b9d14cb6d9b96c9ec32af3":"60d0dec19340d7032ad115a0","58cff8eccebcea42931e0436":"60d0e005b627221e9d819d44","592edf5de0fa177b0c26f95b":"60d0e38fb627221e9d81adcf","58cff72fd85a100b9992c112":"60d0e447b627221e9d81b0da","56b4d34fe4b022697697c400":"60d2472d9340d7032ad7e443","60b8e4c0c5449357a7ad957d":"60e869dc7c5f3b17b6741b81"}},"connatixConfigValues":{"defaultPlayer":"ff7fdddc-5441-4253-abc4-f12a33fad58b","clickToPlayPlayer":"d014396e-b366-4c17-aeac-3ce906fa3fd0","videoPagePlayer":"f010447b-d244-4111-a314-7b4542ae4145","verticalPlayer":"e58cb05a-0bc8-4210-9108-fea82726c065","stickyPlayerControl":"52ea1755-d601-4ad1-bccc-d8cce3f0e5da","stickyPlayerON":"8055e9e5-3bda-4933-8d45-9ad814fb6e22"},"topConnatixThumnbailSrc":"","customAmpComponents":[],"ampAssetsUrl":"https://amp.assets.huffpost.com","videoTraits":null,"positionInUnitCounts":{"buzz_head":{"count":0},"buzz_body":{"count":0},"buzz_bottom":{"count":0}},"positionInSubUnitCounts":{"article_body":{"count":17},"blog_summary":{"count":0},"before_you_go_content":{"count":0}},"connatixCountsHelper":{"count":0},"buzzfeedTracking":{"context_page_id":"5e28b69bc5b6d6767fce70e7","context_page_type":"buzz","destination":"huffpost","mode":"mobile","page_edition":"en-us"},"tags":[{"name":"Culture & Arts","slug":"culture-arts","links":{"relativeLink":"news/culture-arts","permalink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/culture-arts","mobileWebLink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/culture-arts"},"url":"https://action.news/archive/au/topic/culture-arts"},{"name":"oprah winfrey","slug":"oprah-winfrey","links":{"relativeLink":"news/oprah-winfrey","permalink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/oprah-winfrey","mobileWebLink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/oprah-winfrey"},"url":"https://action.news/archive/au/topic/oprah-winfrey"},{"name":"brownface","slug":"brownface","links":{"relativeLink":"news/brownface","permalink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/brownface","mobileWebLink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/brownface"},"url":"https://action.news/archive/au/topic/brownface"},{"name":"jeanine cummins","slug":"jeanine-cummins","links":{"relativeLink":"news/jeanine-cummins","permalink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/jeanine-cummins","mobileWebLink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/jeanine-cummins"},"url":"https://action.news/archive/au/topic/jeanine-cummins"},{"name":"fiction","slug":"fiction","links":{"relativeLink":"news/fiction","permalink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/fiction","mobileWebLink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/fiction"},"url":"https://action.news/archive/au/topic/fiction"},{"name":"Literary criticism","slug":"literary-criticism","links":{"relativeLink":"news/literary-criticism","permalink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/literary-criticism","mobileWebLink":"https://www.huffingtonpost.com.au/news/literary-criticism"},"url":"https://action.news/archive/au/topic/literary-criticism"}],"isLiveblogLive":null,"isLiveblog":false,"cetUnit":"buzz_body","bodyAds":["

\r\n\r\n","

\r\n\r\n"],"adCount":0},"isCollectionEmbed":false,"enhancements":{}}">

What I do see: A book industry thats so out of touch that so rarely supports immigrants to tell our own stories eager to make money off of our suffering with a cheap, stereotypical thrill. #ImNotAmericanDirt . Neither is any immigrant Ive known in 17 years of journalism.
Esmeralda Bermudez (@LATBermudez) January 20, 2020

Cummins herself admitted to being hesitant to write American Dirt in August 2019.

I was resistant, initially, to writing from the point of view of a Mexican migrant because, no matter how much research I did, regardless of the fact that Im Latinx, I didnt feel qualified to write in that voice, she said in an interview with Shelf Awareness .

Cummins added that because these are not my life experiences, she spent several years trying to write the book from a variety of perspectives, and all those perspectives failed. They were terrible. Because, ultimately, they were an inappropriate lens for the telling of this story.

Developing the character of Luca was what changed the whole story and, ultimately, led to American Dirt getting published, Cummins said.

The novelist has not spoken out about the backlash on the book publicly, though she has been retweeting and liking praise shes received for the novel on Twitter.