Billy Eichner congratulated former Bachelor Colton Underwood on Wednesday for coming out as gay with a cheeky and eerily prophetic throwback clip.

The actor and comedian responded to the news by posting footage of his 2019 guest appearance on The Bachelor to his Instagram account. In the clip, he playfully jibes Underwood who was that seasons star about being a self-professed virgin .

Im gay. I know thats a shock, Colton, and that I think you should look into, Eichner tells an exasperated-looking Underwood in the clip. Maybe youre the first gay Bachelor and we dont even know!