Stranger Things actor Gaten Matarazzo traded the spooky environs of Hawkins, Indiana, for the footlights of Broadway this week, and two of his co-stars from the smash Netflix series were there to cheer him on.

The actor made his debut performance in the smash musical Dear Evan Hansen Tuesday as the title characters best friend, Jared Kleinman. His opening night audience included Maya Hawke and Sadie Sink , who star alongside him on Stranger Things.

While backstage visits at Broadway theaters are still prohibited as part of ongoing COVID-19 protocols, Hawke and Sink congratulated their pal from the front row of New Yorks Music Box Theatre after the show.

The trio happily posed together for pictures, too.