Justice Department Argues Against Providing Soap, Toothbrushes, Beds To Detained Kids

A Justice Department attorney this week argued in court that the federal government should not be required to provide soap, toothbrushes or even beds to detained children apprehended at the U.S.-Mexico border.

Government lawyer Sarah Fabian argued Tuesday before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit that forcing children to sleep on cold concrete floors in cells is both safe and sanitary.

Attorneys for the detained children are arguing that the government is not following the requirements of a 1997 settlement agreement in the case of Jenny Flores that established a framework for the humane treatment and release of detained migrant minors. Children must be housed in safe and sanitary conditions under the settlement. A district judge added the specific requirements that children be provided with soap and toothbrushes.

Members of the three-judge appellate panel appeared stunned by Fabians arguments , Courthouse News Service reported.

Are you arguing seriously that you do not read the agreement as requiring you to do something other than what I just described: cold all night long, lights on all night long, sleeping on concrete and youve got an aluminum foil blanket? asked Judge William Fletcher. I find it inconceivable that the government would say that that is safe and sanitary.

Judge Marsha Berzon asked Fabian: Youre really going to stand up and tell us that being able to sleep isnt a question of safe and sanitary conditions?... You cant be sanitary or safe as a human being if you cant sleep. (See the video below at 24:30.)

Fabian was challenging an order by U.S. District Judge Gee in Los Angeles, who appointed an independent monitor to ensure that the federal government complies with the Flores settlement and specifically required such items as soap and toothbrushes. Fabian argued that such requirements are not detailed in the original settlement. (In the video at 26:40.)

One has to assume ... parties couldnt reach agreement on how to enumerate that or it was left to the agencies to determine, Fabian argued.

Fletcher responded: Or it was relatively obvious at least obvious enough so that if youre putting people into a crowded room to sleep on a concrete floor with an aluminum foil blanket on top of them, that doesnt comply with the agreement.

He added: It may be they dont get super-thread-count Egyptian linen, I get that. ... I understand at some outer boundary, there may be some definitional difficulty. But no one would argue that this [current situation] is safe and sanitary.

As for soap, it wasnt perfumed soap, it was soap. That sounds like its part of safe and sanitary, he added. Are you disagreeing with that?

Judge A. Wallace Tashima said that such items are within everybodys common understanding that if you dont have a toothbrush, if you dont have soap, if you dont have a blanket, its not safe and sanitary. Wouldnt everybody agree to that? he asked. Do you agree to that?

Fabian, who appeared to stumble throughout much of her presentation, responded: Well ... maybe.

The attorney for the children argued that, although soap and toothbrushes werent specifically mentioned in the 1997 settlement, they must be provided because they would be reasonably interpreted as part of the agreement under contract law.

The first thing you do is honor the plain meaning of words like safe and sanitary, said Peter Schey. Today we have a situation where once a month a child is dying in custody. Certainly the Border Patrol facilities are secure, but theyre not safe and theyre not sanitary.

Your Support Has Never Been More Critical

Other news outlets have retreated behind paywalls. At HuffPost, we believe journalism should be free for everyone.

Would you help us provide essential information to our readers during this critical time? We can't do it without you.

Can't afford to contribute? Support HuffPost by creating a free account and log in while you read.

You've supported HuffPost before, and we'll be honest we could use your help again . We view our mission to provide free, fair news as critically important in this crucial moment, and we can't do it without you.

Whether you give once or many more times, we appreciate your contribution to keeping our journalism free for all.

Whether you give just one more time or sign up again to contribute regularly, we appreciate you playing a part in keeping our journalism free for all.

Support HuffPost

Its not clear when the 9th Circuit, based in San Francisco, will issue a decision in the case.

The federal government earlier this month stopped English language classes , recreational programs like soccer games and legal aid for locked-up children.

Fabians argument before the 9th Circuit can be seen here:

","type":"video","meta":{"author":"United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit","author_url":"https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCeIMdiBTNTpeA84wmSRPDPg","cache_age":86400,"description":"The Government appeals the district court's judgment and orders enforcing and amending the 1997 Flores Settlement Agreement, which addresses the treatment of minors in custody of the Department of Homeland Security.","options":{"_end":{"label":"End on","placeholder":"ex.: 11, 1m10s","value":""},"_start":{"label":"Start from","placeholder":"ex.: 11, 1m10s","value":""},"click_to_play":{"label":"Hold load & play until clicked","value":false}},"provider_name":"YouTube","thumbnail_height":720,"thumbnail_url":"https://i.ytimg.com/vi/Z2GkDz9yEJA/maxresdefault.jpg","thumbnail_width":1280,"title":"17-56297 Jenny Flores v. William Barr","type":"video","url":"https://action.news/watch?v=Z2GkDz9yEJA","version":"1.0"},"flags":[],"fullBleed":false,"options":{"theme":"news","device":"mobile","editionInfo":{"id":"us","name":"U.S.","link":"https://action.news","locale":"en_US"},"originalEdition":"us","isMapi":false,"isAmp":false,"isVideoEntry":false,"isEntry":true,"isMt":false,"entryId":"5d0c1f37e4b07ae90d9a8b0d","entryPermalink":"https://action.news/entry/justice-department-detained-immigrant-children-soap-toothbrushes_n_5d0c1f37e4b07ae90d9a8b0d","entryTagsList":"family-separation,united-states-department-of-justice,united-states-court-of-appeals-for-the-ninth-circuit,migrant-children,toothbrush","sectionSlug":"politics","deptSlug":"politics-news","sectionRedirectUrl":null,"subcategories":"","isWide":false,"headerOverride":null,"noVideoAds":false,"disableFloat":false,"isNative":false,"commercialVideo":{"provider":"custom","site_and_category":"us.politics","package":null},"isHighline":false,"vidibleConfigValues":{"cid":"60afc111dcf87c2cd2f5d8bf","overrides":{"front_page_top_videos":{"desktop":"60b64354b171b7444beaff4d","mobileweb":"60b64354b171b7444beaff4d"},"top_media":{"desktop":"60b8e6bdc5449357a7ada147","mobile":"60b8e701c5449357a7ada2ee","iphone":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","ipad":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","androidphone":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c","androidtablet":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c"},"anthology":{"desktop":"60b8e616cdd90620331bb0ba","mobile":"60b8e671c5449357a7ad9f66","iphone":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","ipad":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","androidphone":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c","androidtablet":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c"},"content":{"desktop":"60b8e616cdd90620331bb0ba","mobile":"60b8e671c5449357a7ad9f66","iphone":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","ipad":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","androidphone":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c","androidtablet":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c"}},"playerUpdates":{"5668ae6ee4b0b5e26955d6a6":"60d2472d9340d7032ad7e443","56aa41bae4b091744c0440d8":"60e869dc7c5f3b17b6741b81","5841b2b5cc52c716ec6e5a7f":"60b8e355cdd90620331ba185","58b5e2b8d85a10302feee895":"60b64316b171b7444beafdb2","58b74698f78ced31417819ae":"60b8e5bec5449357a7ad9b52","58b74ccecebcea57e2c3a3d1":"60b8e5eac5449357a7ad9ca5","58cff690d85a100b9992bc39":"60b8e616cdd90620331bb0ba","58cffb3fb6d9b972a49a3c9d":"60b8e643cdd90620331bb1f6","58cffdd74d96935d7d6ec180":"60b8e671c5449357a7ad9f66","58d03a84f78ced6518eb2fa7":"60b643c82e76be41f112735c","592edf20e0fa177b0c26f7fd":"60b8e699c5449357a7ada04c","5b35266b158f855373e28256":"60b64354b171b7444beaff4d","5c116f29f79c4171d82b7c2a":"60b64440b171b7444beb040b","5c1170fc600c9a697bf0c6b9":"60b646102e76be41f1127ffc","5c47791afa1b317df8ae0c4f":"60b8e6bdc5449357a7ada147","5c477987a6b48b35f164773d":"60b8e701c5449357a7ada2ee","5c4779ee943c3c2a64f28371":"60b8e747cdd90620331bb861","5c477a26fcd67b26879bc7c2":"60b8e788c5449357a7ada67b","5d8921a78c3ae845f366c9b6":"60ae7be5f3a7c13a30417ff9","58b98b00ba82aa39a6534321":"60d0de7c9340d7032ad1146c","58b9d14cb6d9b96c9ec32af3":"60d0dec19340d7032ad115a0","58cff8eccebcea42931e0436":"60d0e005b627221e9d819d44","592edf5de0fa177b0c26f95b":"60d0e38fb627221e9d81adcf","58cff72fd85a100b9992c112":"60d0e447b627221e9d81b0da","56b4d34fe4b022697697c400":"60d2472d9340d7032ad7e443","60b8e4c0c5449357a7ad957d":"60e869dc7c5f3b17b6741b81"}},"connatixConfigValues":{"defaultPlayer":"ff7fdddc-5441-4253-abc4-f12a33fad58b","clickToPlayPlayer":"d014396e-b366-4c17-aeac-3ce906fa3fd0","videoPagePlayer":"f010447b-d244-4111-a314-7b4542ae4145","verticalPlayer":"e58cb05a-0bc8-4210-9108-fea82726c065","stickyPlayerControl":"52ea1755-d601-4ad1-bccc-d8cce3f0e5da","stickyPlayerON":"8055e9e5-3bda-4933-8d45-9ad814fb6e22"},"topConnatixThumnbailSrc":"https://img.connatix.com/1e35e84f-6da6-4cd2-b3a2-bca7a8f90590/1_th.jpg?crop=480:270,smart&width=480&height=270&format=jpeg&quality=60&fit=crop","customAmpComponents":[],"ampAssetsUrl":"https://amp.assets.huffpost.com","videoTraits":null,"positionInUnitCounts":{"buzz_head":{"count":0},"buzz_body":{"count":0},"buzz_bottom":{"count":0}},"positionInSubUnitCounts":{"article_body":{"count":11},"blog_summary":{"count":0},"before_you_go_content":{"count":0}},"connatixCountsHelper":{"count":1},"buzzfeedTracking":{"context_page_id":"5d0c1f37e4b07ae90d9a8b0d","context_page_type":"buzz","destination":"huffpost","mode":"mobile","page_edition":"en-us"},"tags":[{"name":"family separation","slug":"family-separation","links":{"relativeLink":"topic/family-separation","permalink":"https://action.news/topic/family-separation","mobileWebLink":"https://action.news/topic/family-separation"},"department":{"name":"Latest News","slug":"politics-news"},"section":{"title":"Politics","slug":"politics"},"topic":{"title":"Family Separation","slug":"family-separation","overridesSectionLabel":false},"url":"https://action.news/news/topic/family-separation"},{"name":"United States Department of Justice","slug":"united-states-department-of-justice","links":{"relativeLink":"topic/united-states-department-of-justice","permalink":"https://action.news/topic/united-states-department-of-justice","mobileWebLink":"https://action.news/topic/united-states-department-of-justice"},"department":{"name":"Latest News","slug":"politics-news"},"section":{"title":"Politics","slug":"politics"},"topic":{"title":"United States Department of Justice","slug":"us-department-of-justice","overridesSectionLabel":false},"url":"https://action.news/news/topic/us-department-of-justice"},{"name":"United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit","slug":"united-states-court-of-appeals-for-the-ninth-circuit","links":{"relativeLink":"topic/united-states-court-of-appeals-for-the-ninth-circuit","permalink":"https://action.news/topic/united-states-court-of-appeals-for-the-ninth-circuit","mobileWebLink":"https://action.news/topic/united-states-court-of-appeals-for-the-ninth-circuit"},"relegenceId":3554608,"url":"https://action.news/topic/united-states-court-of-appeals-for-the-ninth-circuit"},{"name":"migrant children","slug":"migrant-children","links":{"relativeLink":"topic/migrant-children","permalink":"https://action.news/topic/migrant-children","mobileWebLink":"https://action.news/topic/migrant-children"},"department":{"name":"Latest News","slug":"politics-news"},"section":{"title":"World News","slug":"world-news"},"topic":{"title":"Migrant And Refugee Crisis","slug":"migrant-crisis","overridesSectionLabel":false},"url":"https://action.news/news/topic/migrant-crisis"},{"name":"toothbrush","slug":"toothbrush","links":{"relativeLink":"topic/toothbrush","permalink":"https://action.news/topic/toothbrush","mobileWebLink":"https://action.news/topic/toothbrush"},"url":"https://action.news/topic/toothbrush"}],"isLiveblogLive":null,"isLiveblog":false,"cetUnit":"buzz_body","bodyAds":["

\r\n\r\n","

\r\n\r\n"],"adCount":0},"isCollectionEmbed":false,"enhancements":{}}">