No longer is Who bit Beyonc? the biggest mystery on the internet.

Former members of boy band *NSYNC reunited for a game of Never Have I Ever on Tuesdays episode of The Ellen DeGeneres Show and Justin Timberlake pretty much revealed that he once hooked up with a Spice Girl .

But now everyone wants to know: Was it Melanie Brown (Scary), Melanie Chisholm (Sporty), Geri Halliwell (Ginger), Emma Bunton (Baby) or Victoria Beckham (Posh)?

For the segment, host Ellen DeGeneres asked the five former bandmates (who split in 2002 ) a series of questions and told them to answer by holding up a paddle which had I Have Never written on one side and I Have on the other.