NEW YORK (AP) Ivanka Trump will have to take the witness stand in the civil fraud case against her father, her brothers and the family business, a judge ruled Friday.

The ruling came weeks into the trial of New York Attorney General Letitia James lawsuit against former President Donald Trump , sons Don Jr. and Eric, the Trump Organization and some executives.

After Ivanka Trump was dismissed from the case months ago, lawyers for her and the defense contended that she shouldnt have to take the stand, noting that she moved out of New York and stepped away from her Trump Organization job in 2017. The states lawyers argued that the former Trump Organization executive vice president has relevant information.

Judge Arthur Engoron sided with the state, citing documents showing that Ivanka Trump has ownership or management ties to some businesses in New York and still owns Manhattan apartments.

Ms. Trump has clearly availed herself of the privilege of doing business in New York, Engoron said. He said her testimony wouldnt be scheduled before Nov. 1, to give her lawyers time to appeal.

James lawsuit accuses the former president of overstating his wealth for years on financial statements that were given to banks, insurers and others to help secure loans and deals.

The defendants deny the allegations. Donald Trump, the current Republican 2024 presidential front-runner, has called the trial a politically motivated sham. James is a Democrat.

The ex-president and his sons are expected to testify at some point. In a surprise preview, the elder Trump ended up briefly on the witness stand Wednesday to answer Engorons questions about an out-of-court comment.

Ivanka Trumps lawyer told the judge Friday that state lawyers had no legal basis to make her testify.

At the end of the day, your honor, they just dont have jurisdiction over her, said the attorney, Bennet Moskowitz.

A state appeals court in June tossed the claims against her as too old. Ivanka Trump announced in January 2017, ahead of her fathers inauguration, that she was stepping away from her Trump Organization job. She soon became an unpaid senior adviser in the Trump White House. After her fathers term ended, she moved to Florida.

The idea that somehow Ms. Trump is under the control of the Trump Organization or any of the defendants, her father anyone who has raised a daughter past the age of 13 knows that theyre not under their control, said Christopher Kise, a lawyer for the ex-president.

Kise maintained that state lawyers just want another free-for-all on another of President Trumps children.

State lawyers, however, argued that Ivanka Trump was a key participant in some events discussed in the case and remains financially and professionally intertwined with the family business and its leaders.

She is 100% someone who can come in and testify, said Kevin Wallace, a lawyer for the attorney generals office.

___

Associated Press writer Michael R. Sisak contributed to this report.