"Who Wore It Better" often features celebrities of similar styles and tastes -- and it almost always features celebs of the same gender.

But this Celine caftan-style silk top, from Phoebe Philo's Spring/Summer 2011 collection, seems to be quite the popular choice for an unlikely trio of celebs: Kanye West, Jessica Simpson and filmaker Sam Taylor-Wood.

West was the first to don the look from the top while performing at Coachella this past summer. We did know the rapper loved high fashion, but we were all a bit suprised to see him grab a womenswear look (at least he wasn't carrying a man purse ).

Next, Jessica Simpson stepped out in the breezy blouse, perhaps intending to hush baby bump rumors .

Finally, the filmaker Taylor-Wood was seen wearing the same look while out with her fiance, the quite young Aaron Johnson (23 years her junior). Taylor-Wood, for one, is actually pregnant and covered her bump with Celine at the weekend wedding of Paul McCarney and Nancy Shevell .

With a shirt this well-traveled and clearly much beloved, we must ask: who wore it better?