DNC Pulls Democratic Debate From UCLA Because Of Union Boycott

The Democratic National Committee says it will no longer hold the sixth presidential debate at the University of California, Los Angeles, choosing to side with a union that has imposed a boycott on the school over a labor dispute.

“In response to concerns raised by the local organized labor community in Los Angeles, we have asked our media partners to seek an alternative site for the December debate,” DNC senior adviser Mary Beth Cahill said Wednesday.

AFSCME 3299 , an affiliate of the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, sent a letter to at least six of the candidates on Tuesday, asking them to respect its boycott on speakers appearing at UC schools until the dispute is resolved. 

In other words, AFSCME 3299 told the candidates that if they support workers’ rights, they need to skip the UCLA debate. 

“What we’re doing is asking for the candidates who are coming to UCLA’s campus to honor the three-year boycott that we’ve had in place for any speaker attending any event on any of the university’s campuses to stand in solidarity with the workers and essentially to not lend their name and credibility to the university that’s treating workers like this,” said Liz Perlman, the union’s executive director.

The December debate will be sponsored by “PBS NewsHour” and Politico.

“This morning, the Democratic National Committee asked our media partners to move the December 19, 2019 debate to another venue following renewed and unanticipated objections from organized labor,” UCLA said in a statement Wednesday. “With regret, we have agreed to step aside as the site of the debate rather than become a potential distraction during this vitally important time in our country’s history.”

It was surprising that UCLA was chosen as the venue for the debate in the first place. Democratic campaigns are generally careful to stay in unionized hotels and use unionized venues for events, since labor is an important constituency of the party. (Although, as HuffPost has reported, some campaigns are better about it than others .) 

The dispute in California centers on UC’s outsourcing of jobs to lower-paid workers. AFSCME 3299 represents 26,000 service and patient care workers in the UC system 91 percent are women of color and they are some of the lowest-paid employees there. 

From AFSCME 3299 President Kathryn Lybarger’s letter to the presidential campaigns: 

Despite UC’s illegal practices to scare AFSCME members and weaken us including allowing violence against members and union staff at picket lines and campaigning to get members to quit the union we are resilient and continue to stand strong. We have gone on strike five times in the past two years over UC’s unfair labor practices and contract demands, and we are ready to do whatever it takes to hold UC accountable to the law and to secure a better future for ourselves and our families. ...

Please join us and endorse this boycott until the University of California commits to addressing our priorities and bargains in good faith with AFSCME 3299.

In a filing with state regulators, AFSCME 3299 alleged that UC is breaking state law by secretly contracting out work, estimating that the school system increased spending on outsourcing of service and patient care jobs by as much as 52 percent in the past three years.

UC has responded that its workers “are not displaced as a result of service subcontracting,” saying that they look outside for short-term needs or when services are not available in-house.

AFSCME has also alleged that a university employee attacked striking workers in October 2018.

AFSCME President Lee Saunders said the union, and its local affiliate, decided to tell the DNC on Tuesday that the boycott needed to be enforced because they weren’t making any progress with the university’s management. 

“When the escalation continued, we decided it would be best if the venue was changed,” he said. 

In a statement after the DNC’s announcement, AFSCME 3299 said it applauded the party’s decision. 

“Just as our next President must heal the divisions in our country, they must also work to confront the staggering inequality and mistreatment of low wage workers that have become all too common in today’s economy,” the union said. “While a change of venue for this debate is no doubt inconvenient, it pales in comparison to the effect that the University’s lawless outsourcing practices are having on thousands of families and communities across California. It is past time for UC to honor the aspirations of those who do the hard, physical work of making this institution run and not just ivory tower elites.”

Several Democratic presidential hopefuls have already shown their support for the workers in the dispute. 

Sen. Kamala Harris (D-Calif.) backed out of delivering the commencement address at UC Berkeley last year, in solidarity with the workers. Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) and former San Antonio Mayor Julián Castro  have each joined the picket line with striking UC employees. 

“Brothers and sisters, what you are doing is enormously important ,” Sanders told the workers during his appearance in March. “You are showing the rest of the country about the importance of standing up and fighting back. You are showing the rest of country what economic justice demands.”

Democratic presidential candidates have been heavily courting the labor community. They have promised to protect collective bargaining rights and consider naming labor leaders to their Cabinets, and backed pro-worker legislation like raising the minimum wage. How union members would fare under a new health care system has been a major topic of conversation. 

But Perlman emphasized that it’s important for candidates to demonstrate their commitment with actions as well as speech.

“In general, I think I’ve heard candidates speak with the right words,” she said. “I’d like to see all the candidates act with the right deeds that show the kind of solidarity with working people. I think that overall every single candidate has, and will, stand with working people more than Donald Trump , for sure. But I also know that we have to hold each other to the highest standard possible because, you know, we’re the ones who we can count on.”

CORRECTION: A previous version of this story said December’s event will be the fifth Democratic presidential debate. It will be the sixth.

This story has been updated with a statement from UCLA, AFSCME 3299 and Lee Saunders.