Unruly Tenants: Moving Day At 1600 Pennsylvania Can Be Rough

By Martin Snapp, originally published on www.californiamag.org

The on-again-off-again dtente between the outgoing and incoming administrations was off before apparently being on againat least, as of this writingwith The Donald tweeting last week, Doing my best to disregard the many inflammatory President O statements and roadblocks. Thought it was going to be a smooth transition - NOT! only to reverse himself a few hours later when he told reporters that the transition was going very, very smoothly.

So has it always been this awkward?

Well, we got off to a good start with the first transition, between George Washington and John Adams in 1796, says Catherine Allgor, former Professor of History at UC Riverside who currently serves as Director of Education at the Huntington Library, Art Collections and Botanical Gardens. It was all going so smoothly, in fact, that in a letter recounting the inauguration that Adams sent to his wife Abigail, he imagines Washington telling him, I am fairly out and you are fairly in. See which of us will be the happiest! But it went downhill very quickly. Four years later at the second transition, between Adams and Thomas Jefferson, feelings were so bitter that Adams left town at four oclock in the morning rather than attend Jeffersons inauguration.

There were also newspaper reports at the time that Adams partisans removed the ropes from the bell clappers at nearby churches so they couldnt ring the bells in Jeffersons honor, an act that Gil Troy, Professor of History at McGill University, calls an ungracious symbolic moment that anticipates the Clinton people, who removed some of the W keys from keyboards in the White House when they left.

Only two other presidents have boycotted their successors inaugurations: Adams son, John Quincy Adams, who stayed away from Andrew Jacksons swearing-in in 1829, and Andrew Johnson, who was absent from Ulysses S. Grants in 1869. Adams was angry because pro-Jackson newspapers had accused him of procuring young American girls for the Russian Czars depraved pleasures when he was minister to Russia anticipating the last elections fake news story about Hillary Clinton running a child sex slave ring out of a Washington DC pizza parlorand Johnson was mad at Grant for refusing to support him during the impeachment crisis.

But its almost come to that several other times, such as 1953, when incoming president Dwight D. Eisenhower broke tradition by refusing to enter the White House for the customary pre-inaugural cup of coffee with the Trumans, preferring to wait in the car with his wife Mamie for Harry and Bess Truman to come out and join them for the ride to the Capitol. Truman responded by declaring he wouldnt attend the inauguration at all, resulting in a tense standoff while the two men waited to see who would blink first. The impasse was finally broken when Bess, who had never been fond of life in the White House, said sternly, Harry, Ive been waiting for eight years to get out of this place, and youre not going to delay me one second longer!

The two men had once been closefour years earlier, Truman had even offered to step down and run as Ikes vice presidentbut all that was forgotten when Eisenhower failed to defend Trumans hero, Gen. George Marshall, who had chosen Ike for supreme command in World War II but was now under attack by Joe McCarthy for supposedly being soft on communism. Hes just a coward, said Truman. He ought to be ashamed for what he did. When Ike heard about that he said, I wonder if I can stand sitting next to this guy.

Things went from bad to worse when Truman surprised Ike by pulling his son, John Eisenhower, who was on active duty in Korea, out of service and flying him back to Washington DC so he could attend his fathers inauguration.

Truman thought he was doing him a favor; but to Ike, that smacked of preferential treatment, and he was furious. He thought Truman was trying to embarrass him, says Carl Anthony, historian at the National First Ladies Library. They were still sniping at each other about it in the car all the way to the Capitol. In his memoir, Upstairs At The White House, chief White House usher J.B. West wrote, I was glad I wasnt in that car.

Ike was still fuming three years later when Trumans presidential library was dedicated. He not only refused to attend the ceremony, he lobbied Herbert Hoover to skip it, too. But Hoover, who after 12 years in the wilderness during Franklin D. Roosevelts presidency was grateful to Truman for rehabilitating his reputation, which included appointing him chairman of the Hoover Commission on government waste and restoring Hoover Dams original name, which FDR had petulantly changed to Boulder Dam, turned him down, saying, I wouldnt miss it.

The Hoover-Roosevelt handoff in 1933 was no love fest either. One of the most famous New Yorker covers of all time, a Peter Arno cartoon depicting a glum Hoover sitting in the car next to a grinning Roosevelt, actually never ran because it was pulled at the last minute due to an assassination attempt a few days earlier that missed FDR but killed Chicago Mayor Anton Cermak, who was standing next to him (Cermaks last words, which are inscribed on his tombstone, were Im glad it was me instead of you, Frank.).

But photographs of the real inaugural parade show that Arnos cartoon, which he drew several weeks before the event, was amazingly prescient, with Roosevelt happily chatting away at an unsmiling Hoover, who was doing his best to ignore him.

The two men had said some nasty things about each other during the campaign. Hoover called Roosevelt a chameleon on plaid, and FDR responded by calling Hoover a fat, timid capon. But Steven Hayward, Ronald Reagan Professor of Public Policy at Pepperdine University, who is a visiting scholar at Cals Institute of Governmental Studies (I wanted to get out of the conservative ghetto for a while, he explains ) says the tension between the two men was political, not personal.

That often happens when the transition is taking place during a crisis, like the Great Depression. The outgoing president wants the incoming president to endorse his policies, and the incoming president doesnt want his hands tied. Hoover wanted to be helpful to Roosevelt, sending him letters asking, Is there something youd like me to begin now? But his letters went unanswered. Roosevelt wanted to start with a clean slate. The downside was that the delay just prolonged the agony of the banks, which were failing.

In 1933, FDR, having experienced the problems caused by a long delay between election and inauguration, which in those days took place on March 4, FDR moved the swearing-in up to its present date, January 20.

Ironically, a lot of people think that, if anything, the too-long transition period has now become too short, says Hayward. For the last 30 years its taken almost a year to fill all the positions at the presidents disposal. Even filling the big, cabinet-level jobs by January 20 is almost impossible, what with FBI checks, Senate hearings, and filibusters.

Daniel Sargent, Associate Professor of History at UC Berkeley, disagrees. The delay were experiencing this time says more about the Trump campaign than it does about the Constitutional order, he says. Were dealing with a campaign that was less prepared for the transition than any campaign since Bob Dole in 96, who had no hope of winning. Every election since then, both the Republican and the Democratic candidates have entertained a reasonable hope of winning, so they planned ahead. But Trump clearly did not to expect to win this, so he was slow getting started. If Kasich had been the nominee he would have been ready to go on November 10.

One complicating factor in any transition is the presidents families, who often take winning and losing even harder than the presidents themselves. No matter who follows you, you know they dont deserve to be there, Betty Ford once said. As she and her husband stood at the door of the White House, waiting for the Carters to arrive for the ride to the Capitol, she turned to him and said, I really dont want to do this.

Youve got to do it, he replied. We have to be good sports here.

Ford was true to his word, giving good advice to the man who beat him, urging him to make friends with House Speaker Tip ONeill, whom Ford got along well with even though they were from opposing parties. Unfortunately, Carter didnt take it.

Carter forgot to invite ONeill to the Inaugural Ball, and everything got off on the wrong foot for the rest of his term, says Terri Bimes, Assistant Research Director at UC Berkeleys Institute of Governmental Studies (though other sources say that Carter invited ONeill but denied his last-minute guests good seats). So when Reagan took over four years later, he made sure to give Tip good seats for the inaugural ceremony and invited him to the ball.

Julia Grant didnt want to leave the White House, either. When the 1876 election between Samuel J. Tilden and Rutherford B. Hayes ended in a deadlock over electoral votes from four states, including Floridasound familiar?Julia thought shed found a way to extend her time as First Lady. She suggested to Ulysses that he remain president until the dispute could be resolved, which could have taken months, even years. He wisely demurred, and when Congress finally decided in favor of Hayes, she wept bitterly as she departed the executive mansion, wailing, Oh, Ulys (her nickname for him)! I feel like a waif, like a waif on the worlds wide common!

Frances Cleveland was even more unwilling to let go. When her husband Grover was defeated for reelection by Benjamin Harrison in 1888, her parting words to the White House staff as she walked out the door were, I want you to take good care of all the furniture and ornaments in the White House, for I want to find everything just as it is now when we come back again four years from today.

And they did come back four years later when Cleveland beat Harrison in a rematch, making him the only president to serve two non-consecutive terms. And true to Frances instructions, everything was just as it was.

Transitions can difficult even between presidents of the same party, such as Reagan and Bush 41 in 1989.

A new president prefers people who are loyal to him, and Bush inherited a lot of people who were loyal to Reagan, says Hayward. There was still a rivalry between the Bush faction and the people who beat them for the nomination eight years (earlier). If Hillary had won this time, Ill bet youd see the same thing between her team and Obamas.

But sometimes presidents rise above the rough-and-tumble of the campaign, even presidents of different parties, such as Carter and Reagan in 1980, who put aside their differences on the morning of the inauguration to collaborate on the freeing of the Iran hostages, after which Reagan sent Carter to Germany to welcome them back.

But the gold standard is the Bush 43-Obama transition in 2008, says Sargent. It showed our democracy at our very best. Bush granted Obamas request to ask Congress to release $350 billion of bank bailout funds, and at the start of his Inaugural address Obama praised Bush for his service to the nation and his generosity during the transition. At a time in history when partisan rancor has stymied the function of our representative democracy, that transition still endures as an example of deference to the national interest, when men and women of both parties were able to come together to orchestrate an orderly, peaceful transition of power. We should cherish that, and Bush and Obama are both to be lauded.

But for sheer graciousness, its hard to beat Bushs father, who in 1993 left his successor, a man hed called a draft dodger, a letter that started a tradition that presidents have followed ever since:

Dear Bill, When I walked into this office just now, I felt the same sense of wonder and respect that I felt four years ago. I know you will feel that, too. I wish you great happiness here. I never felt the loneliness some presidents have described. There will be very tough times, made even more difficult by criticism you may not think is fair. Im not a very good one to give advice; but just dont let the critics discourage you or push you off course. You will be our President when you read this. I wish you well. I wish your family well. Your success now is our countrys success. I am rooting hard for you. Good luck, George